I read it again. It must have been the 100th time. I know I shouldn’t get so annoyed, but what can I say, I must be right at all costs. (at least that’s what my therapist tells me, or told me till I realized she was wrong and fired her)

The offense in question? “Windows 7’s taskbar looks like it copied OS X’s dock.” Now I am not one to talk bad about people for being stupid, I know that it takes all kinds of people to make a world, but follow my logic for a moment here.

Do these two things look alike?

I don’t think so, but let’s make sure, I know this stuff can be very confusing…

How about these?

08271507000_katy%20perry

I am pretty sure there is only one of those I am drooling over.

Let’s try one more…

image

Screen shot 2010-03-29 at 7.28.41 PM

So from a pure aesthetic perspective, it’s a variable sized glossy translucent shelf that holds icons that launch applications or folders, while Windows 7’s taskbar is a single sized, full width bar, flat and transparent, which holds icons (which it identifies as open by jewelling with a square instead of a small glowing light beneath it.) As if visual wasn’t enough differentiation, it’s quite a bit different functionally. I took a close look at it on my PC and Mac, side by side, and created this quick grid to compare features and characteristics:

 

Feature/Characteristic

Windows Task Bar OS X Dock

Full Width of Display

X  

Integrated  Status

X  

Application Sensitive Context Menus

X  

Integrated Search

X  

Application Menu

X  

Hide Capability

X X

Application Launching

X X

Application Window Preview

X  

Multi-Document Preview

X  

Pin Any Folder

  X

Server Connectivity

  X

Trash Integration

  X

Stack View

  X

Magnification

  X

That’s 14 dimensions of measurement and only two of them are shared. Come on, that’s 14% functional symmetry! If you ask me, they are about the same as Peanut Buttery & Jelly sandwiches and Tuna Loaf. I prefer the PB&J.

One last thing to mention, this is Windows 98’s taskbar

dosw98

Does it look more like this?

image

or this?

Screen shot 2010-03-29 at 7.28.41 PM

Yea, I thought so too, so who copied who?

In Mozilla’s Thunderbird email client, the default says that every email that has images from the web is going to have it’s images blocked, and you have to enable the remote content BY email address. This can be really annoying. If you are pretty secure in your email manhood and don’t fear the web, you [...]

In a conversation with a friend this week, I realized that I have mastered a very dark art. I have figured out how to move around between many computers, using them frequently, while never being without my data and information regardless of the computer, the operating system, the browser and the like. I am not [...]

We get so caught up these days in “open source” this and “proprietary” that. Sometimes it’s a good idea to forget the dogma and just talk about what is simply good software. I decided to do this in a top 10 list, and as you will see, it is not tied to either Windows or [...]

I just want to let this quote sink in. This is from one of Google’s engineers talking about their email system Gmail "Gmail was a beta app for a while in itself and that kind of let us as a company not be too afraid about getting something out that may screw up once in [...]

The other day my wife and I were doing the “don’t forget to pick up X at the store” routine. She then came back with, “if you go, don’t forget Y.” Just the a little brilliant hack came to me. I quickly opened up TextEdit on the Mac (notepad for you Windows folks) and write [...]

About this blog

Jason Burns is a technology enthusiast, Microsoft guy, photographer, musician and all around geek. This blog is the general rambling one, check out the links for the specific ones!

Photostream

    Dean VMNT SignatureESP VB.C. Rich VJackson King VMean Water HoseMean Water HoseMean Water HoseNew House - Lived in a littleNew House - Lived in a little
Jason Burns

Create Your Badge